Original video · Aug. 13, 2026
The Speed of Light Is a Property of the Medium
Ashton examines Michelson–Morley, Maxwell's equations, vacuum permittivity/permeability, gravity and a claimed vertical-interferometer result.
Privacy-enhanced YouTube playback loads only after you press Play.
Vote Motta 2028 · Share this exact science review
Ashton Forbes — The Speed of Light Is a Property of the Medium
Shares return to this exact video, evidence labels and testing protocol.
https://www.votemotta2028.com/creator-spotlight/ashton-forbes.php#ashton-youtube-AJD0IAc1CisOriginal source: Ashton Forbes on YouTube ↗
Claim vs. evidence
What should voters take away?
Ashton's claim A vertical version of Michelson–Morley shows a significant effect and supports the return of a physical medium / ether interpretation.
Mainstream result Michelson–Morley reported a null result for classical ether drift, and increasingly precise modern tests have continued to find no Lorentz-violating anisotropy at the expected scale.
Vertical orientation is not a clean shortcut Gravity, mechanical deformation, temperature gradients, tilt and alignment can all change optical path lengths and fringe positions.
Campaign position Don't settle it by authority or ridicule. Define the predicted signal, instrument the confounders, preregister the analysis and replicate it independently.
Open-testing protocol
What experiment would be persuasive?
- Publish exact interferometer geometry, wavelength, materials, mounting and orientation.
- State the predicted fringe shift for the proposed medium model before collecting data.
- State the special/general-relativistic prediction and expected gravitational contribution.
- Log temperature gradients, vibration, tilt, barometric pressure and material strain.
- Rotate between horizontal and vertical configurations using the same instrument when practical.
- Use blinded or preregistered analysis and release raw time-series/fringe data.
- Have an independent lab reproduce the apparatus and analysis.
- Define in advance what result would falsify the medium/ether interpretation.